How to spot a fake email: what I learnt when someone pretended to be me

Fake email sent from a lookalike Gmail address using Theo Ruby’s name

Last week a client sent me a screenshot of an email they’d received. It had my name on it, my job title, and a link to my website. I hadn’t sent it.

Someone had set up a free Gmail account in a name close to mine and used it to email a few of my clients about their domain renewals. Nothing was hacked. They simply copied details that are already public.

I’ve worked in digital marketing since 2008 and I’ve seen plenty of spam, but this was the first time someone had pretended to be me. So here’s what happened, how to spot a fake email in a few seconds, and the simple steps that protect your own website and domain.

The short version

  • Check the address an email was sent from, not the name shown beside it.
  • The part after the @ sign matters most. Mine is only ever theo@theoruby.com.
  • If you’re unsure, don’t reply or click. Contact the person another way, then forward the email to report@phishing.gov.uk.

What the fake email looked like

The email came from theo.rubbys@gmail.com and was headed “Domain Renewal And Website Updates”. The wording was clumsy and it read like spam, but the topic was believable. Domains and websites are exactly what I write to clients about.

There was no lottery win and no prince leaving millions to a stranger. It was short, focused, and sent to people who actually work with me. That’s what makes this kind of email harder to dismiss than the old-style scams.

Most people deleted it straight away. One person replied before realising something wasn’t right. They didn’t share any details or pay anything, but it still left them feeling shaken, which is exactly why I wanted to write this.

As far as I can tell, the sender took my name and job title from my website, and found some of my clients through the “website by” credit at the bottom of sites I’ve built. Nobody had access to my systems, my clients’ websites, or anyone’s data.

Why are fake emails harder to spot now?

For years the advice was to look out for bad spelling and far-fetched stories. That advice is wearing out. The National Cyber Security Centre’s assessment of AI, published in January 2024, says AI tools can already write scam messages without the spelling and grammar slips that used to give them away.

The numbers are huge too. When I reported the fake email, the NCSC’s reporting service said it had received 59.6 million reports. Its 2026 annual review says 13.4 million came in between September 2025 and August 2026, the most in a year since the service started.

Phishing is also the most common attack on UK businesses by far. In the government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025, 85% of businesses that had a breach or attack said it involved phishing.

None of this is a reason to panic or distrust every email. It just means the wording is no longer the test to rely on. The sender’s address is.

How do you spot a fake email?

Always check the address the email was sent from, not the name shown beside it. Anyone can set the display name to whatever they like. On a phone, tap the sender’s name and the full address appears.

Then read the address slowly. Mine is theo@theoruby.com. The fake one was theo.rubbys@gmail.com, with an extra “b”, an added “s”, and a Gmail ending.

My only address
theo@theoruby.com
The fake one
theo.rubbys@gmail.com

The part after the @ sign matters most. Anyone can open a Gmail, Outlook, or Yahoo account in a couple of minutes and give it any name. An address at a business’s own domain is much harder to fake, as long as the domain is set up properly, which I cover below.

If you’re still unsure, don’t reply to the email. Contact the person using details you already have, or the ones on their own website. That’s also the advice in the NCSC’s guide to spotting scam messages.

6 simple habits that keep you safe online

  1. Check the sender’s address on anything unexpected, especially if it mentions money, renewals, or passwords.
  2. Be wary of deadlines. “Pay by Friday or lose your domain” is pressure, and the NCSC lists urgency as one of the main signs of a scam.
  3. Don’t click the link in the email. Go to the website yourself, or ring the person on a number you already have.
  4. Never send passwords or card details by email. No genuine supplier needs them that way.
  5. Turn on two-step verification for your email account. It’s the account that resets all your others, so it’s the one most worth protecting.
  6. Report it, then delete it. Forward suspicious emails to report@phishing.gov.uk, the NCSC’s free reporting address.

What to do if you get a fake email

Don’t reply, don’t click, and don’t pay. Forward it to report@phishing.gov.uk, then delete it. The NCSC explains how reporting works, and it has the power to take scam addresses and websites down, so every report helps.

If the email claims to be from someone you know, tell them using contact details you already have. They’ll want to warn other people, as I did.

If you’ve already replied or clicked, don’t panic. Change any password you shared, and ring your bank if you gave card or bank details. If you’ve lost money, report it to Report Fraud in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland, or to Police Scotland on 101.

How do you protect your own domain?

Your domain name is the address of your website and your email, so it’s worth a few minutes of care. These four things cover most of it.

  • Know where it’s registered. Make sure the account is in your name, with an email address you still use.
  • Turn on auto-renew, and add two-step verification to that account.
  • Treat a renewal notice from a company you don’t recognise as suspect. Renewals only come from the company you registered with, or from whoever manages the domain for you.
  • Use an email address at your own domain for your business, not a free one. It gives your clients something clear to check.

There’s also a setting that stops other people sending email that claims to come from your domain. It’s made up of three records called SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, which tell other mail servers which emails are really yours and what to do with the rest.

Whoever looks after your email or website can set them up. I check all three as part of my website spam blocking and email fixes. The NCSC also has a free Check your cyber security tool that tests whether your email could be spoofed, with no registration needed.

What I’m doing to protect my clients

I only ever send email from theo@theoruby.com. If something arrives in my name from any other address, it isn’t from me, so please ignore it and let me know.

My own domain is already set to reject email that fails those three checks, and I’m adding extra security across the websites I host and maintain. I’ll also be running a short online session on staying safe online soon.

Trust works both ways. The same signals that make an email believable, a real name, a real address, and clear contact details, are what make a website feel safe to visitors. If you’re a therapist, my guide to E-E-A-T for therapists and free trust factors audit tool show you how to build them into your own site.

If you’re not sure whether your domain is protected, or you’ve had an email you’re unsure about, get in touch and I’ll take a look.

Quick questions

Was Theo Ruby Marketing hacked?

No. The email came from a separate Gmail account that someone created. Nothing of mine or my clients’ was accessed.

It’s possible if your domain has no SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records, because nothing tells other mail servers to refuse the forgery. With those records set up properly, it becomes very difficult.

It isn’t unsafe in itself. The drawback is that anyone can create a similar-looking address, so an email address at your own domain gives clients a much clearer way to know it’s really you.

In the iPhone Mail app, tap the sender’s name at the top of the email. In the Gmail app, tap the small arrow under the sender’s name. Both show the full address the email came from.

A lookalike is a different address made to resemble the real one, like the Gmail account used here. A spoofed email forges the real address itself. SPF, DKIM, and DMARC stop spoofing, but only checking the address catches a lookalike.

Forward the email to report@phishing.gov.uk first. You can also report the account to Google through its Gmail abuse form.

Related guides

About the author

Theo Ruby is the founder of Theo Ruby Marketing, a UK consultancy that builds websites and runs SEO for therapists, counsellors, and wellness practitioners, and for small businesses in West London. He has worked in marketing since 2008, has run the business since 2017, and has worked with more than 300 clients. He hosts and maintains more than 100 client websites, speaks regularly to therapy groups about websites and marketing, and holds a BBA (Hons) in Business Administration and Marketing from the University of Kent.

Last updated: 18 November 2026

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter